Buy S&P Minis Futures on SPY Dip — Backtest
Strategy 1102 · MES futures, long only, 3x leverage · daily SPY signal, orders at 16:05 ET · real prices Nov 14, 2024 – Nov 13, 2026; estimate Oct 18, 2016 – Nov 13, 2026 · idle money in SGOV
25.3%
Return per year (2016+ estimate)
Growth of $10,000
Buy S&P Minis Futures on SPY Dip (3x, estimate)Buy and hold SPY
Both lines start at $10,000. The strategy line is the 2016+ estimate at 3x leverage, including Treasury bill income on the capital and trading costs. SPY prices are split- and dividend-adjusted.
Rules
- Signal: z = (close − 5-day average) / 5-day standard deviation, on SPY's daily closes.
- Buy (when flat): z ≤ −1.5 and the close is above its 200-day average.
- Sell (when holding): at the first close where z ≥ +1.5, or 10 trading days have passed, or SPY's close is at least 5% below the entry-day close.
- Re-entry: never on the same day as an exit. Long only.
- Instrument: the front Micro E-mini S&P 500 futures contract (MES, $5 per index point). A position held on roll day, the Thursday of the week before the quarterly expiry, is moved to the next contract.
- Orders: decided at the stock market close, market orders at 16:05 ET while futures are still open.
- Size: one contract (about $37,890 of exposure) at 3x leverage, so about $12,630 of capital.
- Idle money: SGOV, a Treasury bill ETF. During a trade, cash worth 15% of the position is held for margin.
Real MES prices, Nov 14, 2024 – Nov 13, 2026
These two years are all the expired-contract price history Interactive Brokers provides. 27 trades, 78% winners. Over the same two years the estimate used below gives 41.3% a year at 3x, against 41.4% on the real prices, so the estimate tracks actual MES closely.
Estimate, Oct 18, 2016 – Nov 13, 2026
Estimate since 2023
Results by year (3x, estimate)
Trades (3x, as a share of capital)
Margin safety
- Futures margin is about 6.5% of the position's value. At 3x the account starts each trade with 33%, so a margin call needs MES to fall about 29% during a single trade (47% at 2x).
- The largest fall during any trade was 6.0% on real prices (measured at 5-minute lows) and 6.1% in the 2016+ estimate (measured at daily closes). At 3x that left equity at 29% and 29% of the position's value, against a requirement of about 6.5%. No margin call in either test.
- The strategy's 5% stop, checked at each close, normally ends a trade long before a margin call is possible.
- Futures gains and losses are settled in cash every day. The 15% cash reserve covers the margin and a 5% fall; beyond that the broker lends against the SGOV holding.
Assumptions
- Costs are $0.62 in commission and exchange fees plus one tick ($1.25) of slippage per contract per side, about 0.5 basis points of the position. A roll costs two more sides.
- In the real-price test MES is bought and sold at its 16:05 ET price and valued each day at its 16:00 ET price.
- In the estimate, MES earns SPY's total return minus the Treasury bill rate, because a futures price includes the cost of financing the position. Entries and exits use SPY's 19:55 ET price where it is on file.
- All capital earns the Treasury bill ETF return (SGOV, BIL before 2020) every day. The cash reserve held during a trade would earn somewhat less in practice.
- Margin of 6.5% is an estimate from Interactive Brokers' requirement for the full-size contract; it was not confirmed for MES, and the broker can raise it.
- The position is modelled as exactly 3x of capital. Live, it is one whole contract, so the leverage drifts with the index level and the account's value. SPY prices are Alpaca SIP daily bars, adjusted for splits and dividends.
Risks
- Leverage triples losses. Drawdown and the worst day are about three times the unleveraged version's. A trade stopped out at 5% costs about 15% of capital; the worst in the estimate cost 16.4%.
- Weak years. See 2018 and 2022 in the table above: few trades, mostly losers.
- Gaps. The stop is checked at the close only. Futures trade nearly around the clock, so a fall can build overnight before the next check.
- Short real-price history. Only two years of actual MES prices were available. The ten-year result is an estimate.
- Margin changes. A higher margin requirement in a volatile market brings the margin-call level closer.
- Chosen in hindsight. The parameters were picked with this history available; live results are usually weaker than a backtest.
Generated Nov 15, 2026 by ibk/mes_dip_buyer_backtest_report.py. Backtests use past prices and simple cost assumptions; past results don't guarantee future returns.