At a glance
| Weekly Bull Put Spread (AAPL) | |
|---|---|
| Live paper trading (Oct 26 – Nov 13) | +$493 on 3 trades, 3 winners |
| Credit collected / maximum loss per trade | $90–$249 / $751–$1,276 |
| Share of the credit kept at exit | 78–97% |
| Worst open mark | −$401 (Nov 3, 9:35 a.m.) |
| Backtest (117 weeks, per contract) | −$280, 84 wins / 33 losses |
| Backtest average win / average loss | +$78 / −$206 |
| Backtest max drawdown / worst week | $1,769 / −$625 |
Three for three, but one win was a near miss. The week of November 2, the strategy sold its spread hours before Apple reported quarterly results. AAPL opened Tuesday 3.8% lower, below the 335 short strike, and the position was down about $401 of a possible $751. A Wednesday rally turned it into a $193 gain.
The strategy doesn’t know when Apple reports. It opens every Monday with no earnings or volatility check. That week’s credit was $249, against $90 the week before: the extra premium was the market pricing the earnings move, and the strategy collected it without deciding to.
The backtest loses money. Across 117 weeks the strategy won 72% of the time, but its average loss was 2.6 times its average win. That needs a win rate of about 73% just to break even, and three live wins don’t change that arithmetic.
How the strategy works
| Structure | Sell a put about 2% below AAPL; buy a put about 5% below. Both strikes rounded to the nearest $5. |
| Expiry | That week’s Friday |
| Entry | Monday 9:40 ET (first trading day of the week), one 2-leg market order |
| Filters | None: no trend, volatility, credit or earnings check |
| Exit | Thursday 3:45 ET (the day before expiry), one 2-leg market order |
| Profit target / stop loss | None |
| Account | Our own paper account, 1 contract, shared with three other weekly spread strategies on different stocks |
What it’s betting on. A bull put spread collects a credit up front and keeps all of it if AAPL stays above the short strike through Thursday. Below the short strike the loss grows dollar for dollar until the long put caps it, at the spread width less the credit. It is a bullish trade: it wins if AAPL rises, holds steady, or falls less than about 2%.
The week of November 2
The strategy opened at 9:40 a.m. Monday with AAPL at 340.61. It sold the 335 put and bought the 325 put for a $249 credit, so the most it could lose was $751. Rounding to the nearest $5 put the short strike only 1.65% below AAPL rather than 2%.
Apple reported its fiscal fourth-quarter results after Monday’s close. Its gross-margin guidance for the December quarter came in below analysts’ estimates, which coverage tied to rising memory-chip costs. AAPL opened Tuesday at 325.58, through the short strike and just above the long put, and closed the day at 331.90.
AAPL, November 2–5, against the spread’s strikes
| Day | AAPL close | Spread at close | Day’s worst |
|---|---|---|---|
| Mon Nov 2 (entry 340.61) | 338.32 | −$54 | −$98 |
| Tue Nov 3 (after earnings) | 331.90 | −$151 | −$401 |
| Wed Nov 4 | 349.51 | +$235 | +$139 |
| Thu Nov 5 (exit at 3:45) | 345.93 at exit | +$193 (filled) | +$159 |
Marks use each leg’s last trade price each minute, so intraday figures are approximate; the +$193 is the actual fill. AAPL closes are official daily closes.
Why it recovered. AAPL bounced to close at 349.51 on Wednesday, well above the short strike, and the position kept most of its credit. On Thursday the S&P 500 fell about 4%; AAPL slipped only about 1% by the 3:45 exit, and the spread closed at +$193.
Why that was luck, not design. The strategy has no stop loss, so it simply held through the Tuesday low. Had AAPL kept falling below 325, the full $751 loss would have stood. A stop would have locked in a loss on Tuesday morning. Either way, the outcome was decided by an earnings report the strategy didn’t know was coming.
Earnings timing. In recent years Apple has usually reported on a Thursday after the close, after this strategy’s 3:45 p.m. Thursday exit. This quarter it reported on a Monday, inside the holding period.
Live paper trading
One contract on our own paper account. Results come from Alpaca fills, so they’re net of the spread actually paid.
| Week of | Strikes | Credit | Max loss | AAPL in → out | Short strike below AAPL | Worst mark | P&L |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Oct 26 | 335/325 | $90 | $910 | 343.20 → 349.41 | 2.4% | −$34 | +$87 |
| Nov 2 | 335/325 | $249 | $751 | 340.61 → 345.93 | 1.7% | −$401 | +$193 |
| Nov 9 | 345/330 | $224 | $1,276 | 349.83 → 355.31 | 1.4% | −$61 | +$213 |
| Total | 3 trades, 3 winners | +$493 | |||||
Strikes are short put / long put. AAPL prices are the first and last regular-hours prices of each holding period. Worst mark is approximate (see above).
The two calmer weeks behaved as designed: AAPL drifted up, and the spreads kept 97% and 95% of their credit. The live credits, averaging $188, are almost double the backtest’s $98 average. Part of that is AAPL’s higher price, and part is the earnings premium in the November 2 week.
Rounding moves the risk around
Both strikes are rounded to the nearest $5. With AAPL near $345, $5 is about 1.4% of the price, so the short strike can land anywhere from about 1.3% to 2.7% below AAPL, and the width between the strikes can be $5, $10 or $15.
| Week of | AAPL at entry | 2% below | Short strike | 5% below | Long strike | Width |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Oct 26 | 343.20 | 336.34 | 335 | 326.04 | 325 | $10 |
| Nov 2 | 340.61 | 333.80 | 335 | 323.58 | 325 | $10 |
| Nov 9 | 349.83 | 342.83 | 345 | 332.34 | 330 | $15 |
In two of the three weeks the short strike rounded up, closer to AAPL than intended. On November 9 the strikes also rounded apart, to a $15 spread, so the maximum loss rose to $1,276. In the backtest the short strike sat anywhere from 0.7% to 3.3% below AAPL. None of this is deliberate: it is a by-product of rounding two percentages independently.
What the backtest says
Our backtest prices every Monday entry from January 22, 2024 to June 22, 2026 with real option prices, entering at Monday’s open and closing at Thursday’s close, with the same 2% / 5% strikes. It was run at 10 contracts; the figures below are per contract.
| 117 weekly trades, per contract, gross | |
|---|---|
| Total P&L | −$280 |
| Winners | 84 (72%) |
| Average win / average loss | +$78 / −$206 |
| Win rate needed to break even | about 73% |
| Average credit / average maximum loss | $98 / $603 |
| Losses larger than $200 | 16, totaling −$5,467 |
| Worst week | −$625 (week of Mar 31, 2025) |
| Max drawdown | $1,769 |
| By year | 2024 −$341 · 2025 −$120 · 2026 (to June) +$181 |
Backtest: cumulative P&L per contract
The arithmetic is the problem. The strategy collects about $98 to risk about $600. It wins most weeks, but 16 losses of more than $200 erased most of what the 84 winners made. A single bad week, like the tariff sell-off at the start of April 2025, costs about eight average wins.
The 2026 recovery didn’t hold. A long run of wins from February to early June 2026, while AAPL climbed from about $260 to $310, took the backtest briefly into profit. Two losses in June put it back underwater. The live period, so far, looks like that winning stretch: AAPL has risen from about $343 to $355.
The published backtest page also shows an annualized return. We don’t use it here: it scales a small per-trade figure by the year and divides by capital at risk, and with a negative total it says little beyond what the table above shows.
Operational notes
- No event filter. The strategy opens every Monday regardless of earnings, economic releases or volatility. The November 2 week is the clearest example.
- Market orders. Entry and exit are 2-leg market orders. A limit order at the mid would control slippage in a fast market.
- No stop or target. Positions are held from Monday to Thursday. The worst case is the full width less the credit, $751–$1,276 per contract in the live trades.
- Shared account. The paper account also runs weekly spreads on MU, XLK and AMZN. We attribute P&L from the AAPL option fills only, so account-level equity figures don’t apply to this strategy.
- The backtest is stale. It ends June 25, 2026, before the live period, and exits at Thursday’s close rather than 3:45 p.m.
What we’re watching
- An earnings filter. We want to test skipping (or closing early) any week in which Apple reports before the Thursday exit, and see what that does to the backtest’s worst weeks.
- Consistent strikes. Rounding the short strike down, never closer than 2%, and setting the long strike a fixed distance below it would keep the risk the same from week to week. We plan to backtest that version.
- A current backtest. Extending the backtest through November under today’s exit time, so the live trades can be compared with it directly.
- More trades. Three trades say little. The backtest’s losses arrive a few times a year, so a fair live test needs months, not weeks.
Sources and methodology
- Scope. The Weekly Bull Put Spread (AAPL) strategy as it trades today, one contract on our own paper account, from October 26, 2026. Earlier versions ran on a different account at 10 contracts and are not covered here.
- Live. Alpaca paper-trading fills for AAPL options on that account, October 26 – November 12, 2026 (the last exit). Our total matches the strategy’s performance report (+$493).
- Prices. AAPL 1-minute SIP bars and option 1-minute bars from Alpaca. Intraday spread marks use each leg’s last trade price, so they are approximate.
- Earnings. Apple reported fiscal fourth-quarter 2026 results after the close on November 2, 2026, as covered by 9to5Mac and 24/7 Wall St.
- Backtest. Our weekly backtest of the strategy, January 22, 2024 – June 22, 2026 entries, real OPRA option prices, Monday open to Thursday close, 10 contracts, no commissions or slippage. Per-contract figures are the published results divided by 10.
See how every strategy we run is doing, updated each trading day, on the live leaderboard.
Results are from paper-trading accounts and backtests and do not reflect real money. Paper and backtest results may differ materially from live trading. Past performance does not guarantee future results. This note is research and education, not investment advice or a recommendation to trade any strategy or security. Options involve substantial risk and are not suitable for all investors.